Skip to main content
Aerial top-down view of a large artificial turf sports field with white field markings and goal posts casting long shadows. Bright green grass texture and geometric layout captured by drone photography.
licensed photo: Shutterstock

F10 and the Questions Facing Rugby’s Wider Game

Funding, relegation and access for Ireland, Wales and unions beyond the ten

11.11.26, 21:08

The most important development since the ten leading unions announced a joint commercial rights agency is the debate over what happens if one of them is relegated from the Nations Championship. The issue joins two questions that were already open: how the ten will share income among themselves, and whether unions outside the group can share in the value created by the competitions they help make compelling. For Ireland, the first funding decisions remain with the IRFU. For clubs and grassroots rugby, no direct F10 payment has been announced. For the likes of Wales and other unions, the emerging question is whether commercial security will be matched by open competition and a credible route to future participation.

What the ten have agreed and what they have not

The Six Nations unions and the four SANZAAR unions have agreed to pool rights from a wider group of properties, including the Six Nations, Rugby Championship, Nations Championship, British & Irish Lions tours and the New Zealand–South Africa rivalry series. A new agency, provisionally referred to in reporting as F10, is expected to manage sales. The Irish Examiner’s report on the agreement says Southern Hemisphere unions would share in revenue generated by the Six Nations and Lions tours, while European unions would benefit from deals linked to the Rugby Championship and the rivalry series.

The commercial case is straightforward: a larger package may be easier to sell, strengthen the unions’ bargaining position and make international rugby more attractive to broadcasters and sponsors. Sponsorship and other commercial arrangements are expected to be affected from 2028. The current broadcast contracts run through 2029, so the next major television rights cycle begins in 2030. RFU chief executive Bill Sweeney described the agency as a more efficient way to sell rights, with the aim of increasing valuations and growing commercial income.

The Times report on the revenue split says a broad revenue split between the European and southern hemisphere groups has been agreed, weighted in favour of Europe. The ten have not published the detailed allocation formula, agency governance, costs, minimum guarantees or any development commitment. Nor does F10 replace World Rugby as the sport’s governing body. The Rugby World Cup remains outside the reported rights pool. The difference between commercial coordination and governance matters, but commercial rights can still shape who has financial security, influence and access to major fixtures.

The new fault line is promotion and relegation

World Rugby’s Nations Championship is scheduled to move to a promotion and relegation format from 2030. The competition was approved in 2023 on the basis that it would become open, with a route for a Nations Cup team to move up. World Rugby’s current explanation says stakeholders will examine the mechanism from that edition onward; the 2023 calendar announcement and the Nations Cup guide set out the intended direction, while the rules still need to be settled.

On 10 November, reporting by The Irish Times and The Guardian described a fresh dispute. Some unions are reportedly seeking safeguards against relegation, with Wales and Italy named as examples. The reports say World Rugby and smaller unions want Nations Cup rights bundled with the Nations Championship rights, which could give the second-tier unions a share of the commercial proceeds. The Nations Championship had secured more than 80 broadcast deals for its 2026 edition, compared with 13 for the Nations Cup, according to the Irish Times report.

The reporting also records two different public positions. Six Nations sources say relegation will be introduced as envisaged, while the outstanding financial issue is the support given to a union that drops down. WRU chief executive Abi Tierney has warned that relegation would be “cataclysmic” for Wales. Bill Sweeney said a World Rugby review group chaired by Brett Robinson was examining how promotion and relegation would operate, while maintaining that the basic premise remained. These statements indicate concern about financial consequences; they do not establish that the ten have formally agreed to abolish relegation.

That distinction matters. A parachute payment could cushion the loss of top-tier revenue without removing the competitive consequence. Exemptions or a closed league would be a different decision and, according to the reports, would reopen the terms on which the Nations Championship was approved. The commercial agency is therefore prompting scrutiny not only of how the ten divide money among themselves, but also of whether a team’s place in the most valuable tier is protected by sporting results.

Ireland and the route from club to union

Any F10 income for Ireland would first flow to the IRFU as one of the ten rights-holders. It would then be considered within the union’s overall budget and funding model. There is no announced percentage for the four provinces, no direct club dividend and no published ring-fencing for grassroots rugby. A stronger commercial position could give the IRFU more options, but its effect below the international level would depend on the union’s allocation decisions.

Ireland already has established funding routes. The IRFU’s 2024 funding review set annual provincial funding at approximately €40 million and introduced a more transparent formula, incentives connected to future EPCR and URC income, and matched funding. In 2024/25, the union reported €16.4 million of domestic and community investment, including exceptional capital and matched-funding initiatives. Its financial report recorded €1 million in additional provincial matched funding and €1.1 million in approved Strategic Infrastructure Fund grants for 18 clubs, from 88 applications.

The funding relationship also runs in both directions. Effective 1 August 2026, provinces are contributing 40% of the cost of national player contracts. The IRFU said the funds released would be ring-fenced for player pathways in Connacht, Munster and Ulster. The funding change announcement illustrates how responsibilities can shift between union and provinces as priorities change. It does not tell us how any F10 income will be used.

Provinces could benefit if new commercial income helps sustain their allocations, pathways, facilities or multi-year planning. Clubs could benefit if the IRFU or provinces choose to expand grants, participation programmes or infrastructure support. Those are plausible routes, not automatic effects. Clubs need not assume that F10 will take money away from existing support, but they are entitled to ask whether new income will be additional, how it will be reported and whether the funding outlook below the elite level is stable.

Wales and the three-team plan

Wales’s three-team proposal is a domestic restructuring choice that predates the F10 agreement. The WRU has said that it intends to move to three men’s professional clubs from 2028/29, in Cardiff, East Wales and West Wales. Its 2025 announcement proposed equal squad funding beginning at £6.4 million and rising to £7.8 million per year; the 2026 operating-model roadmap says the licensing process is expected to run from December 2026 to the end of the 2026/27 season.

F10 could add to the WRU’s commercial income as one of the ten owners, but no allocation formula has been published and no evidence links F10 revenue to the number of Welsh teams. It cannot yet be treated as a funding solution for the three-team structure or as a reason to restore a fourth professional side. The move to three teams still carries a regional and sporting cost. Fewer professional environments and a changed map of representation. Any future income could improve the union’s overall capacity, but it would not by itself resolve the consequences of that choice.

The relegation debate adds another uncertainty for Wales. Tierney’s public warning reflects the potential financial consequences of dropping to the Nations Cup. If the ten seek protection, the question will be whether they pursue a transparent financial safety net or a sporting exemption. Those options should not be conflated, and their implications for the Welsh model cannot be judged until the rules and payments are clear.

Access for Spain, Japan and the Nations Cup unions

Other examples worth considering are there to be seen. Spain’s Rugby World Cup 2035 bid shows ambition beyond the founding ten. Spain has formal government backing for its bid, and has also reportedly expressed informal interest in hosting the 2028 Nations Championship finals after Qatar withdrew. Qatar’s exit also removed its planned title-sponsorship arrangement; France and Spain are among those reported to be interested in the replacement hosting opportunity. The Guardian’s report on Qatar’s withdrawal says an invitation to tender is planned for early 2027. Hosting a final or bidding for a World Cup can create opportunities, but neither gives Spain an ownership share in F10. World Cup rights remain outside the agency’s reported remit.

Japan and Fiji are invited into the first three editions of the Nations Championship, but the current reporting says they receive appearance fees rather than a share of the pooled commercial rights. The Nations Cup gives twelve other unions a regular fixture platform. That is meaningful access, but its smaller broadcast footprint and uncertain future promotion rules leave a gap between taking part and sharing in the commercial value. World Rugby and the Nations Cup unions’ request to bundle the two competitions would address part of that gap, though there is no public agreement to do so yet.

A larger international rights package might grow demand for rugby beyond the ten. It might also strengthen the ten’s control over the most valuable properties while other unions remain reliant on invitations, qualification, development funding and occasional hosting. The key test is whether the model creates credible movement between tiers and a fair commercial relationship with teams whose participation helps sustain the product.

The cricket comparison and wider risks

Cricket’s Big Three episode remains a useful warning about distribution rules and influence. In 2014, India, England and Australia gained a stronger position in ICC governance and central revenue arrangements, while South Africa sat outside that core. The ICC reversed those resolutions in 2017, but later distributions remained unequal: for 2024–27, India was reported to receive about 38.5% of annual net earnings, compared with 6.89% for the ECB and 6.25% for Cricket Australia. The ICC’s 2014 account, its 2017 revision and The Indian Express’s report on the current allocation show why the rules need scrutiny. Rugby differs: South Africa is one of the ten owners, and F10 is described as a rights agency rather than a transfer of World Rugby’s governance. The comparison is a caution, not a prediction.

There are also questions about the experience of supporters and players. Following the inaugural Nations Championship rounds, some commentators criticised travel demands, fixture sequencing and venues, arguing that the competition’s commercial design could take priority over supporter access and player welfare. The Guardian’s analysis is opinion, but it raises practical issues the organisers will need to address if the competition is to build lasting interest. A valuable rights package depends on sporting credibility and audience trust as well as negotiations with broadcasters.

What to watch next

Several decisions will show whether F10 creates broader value or primarily secures the position of its owners: publication of the revenue formula and governance rules; the Nations Cup’s inclusion or exclusion from future rights packages; the promotion and relegation mechanism and any financial support for relegated teams; the replacement host and sponsor arrangements for the 2028 finals; and the way unions account for new income in their domestic budgets.

For Ireland, the practical measure will be whether F10 income supports a sustainable funding path from the IRFU through provinces to clubs, participation and facilities. For Wales, it will be whether any additional income sits transparently alongside the three-team decision and its pathway commitments. For Spain and the other unions outside the ten, it will be whether access to competitions, hosting opportunities and the commercial value of the wider game can develop into a credible route to more influence. As of 11 November 2026, the agency’s commercial ambition is clear; its distribution rules and its relationship with the rest of the game are not.

Justin Deegan

Justin Deegan is a sports administration manager and consultant with expertise in governance, organisational and cultural management and change. He has more than 20 years’ experience across Irish sport, including rugby development, grassroots programmes, major events, club support and sports operations.

More like this

Get started with our free newsletter

Sign up to receive your free newsletter with articles and analysis from our team

By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from The Leinster Playbook.